I’d say 4.5 really at this moment in time. I didn’t give a 5 because I don’t feel like I’ve been wearing them long enough and haven’t truly tested them out.
I’ve only been wearing them for a little less than a month. I rotate through a few pairs of shoes so I don’t wear them everyday. So far they have been absolutely great to walk around and stand in. Haven’t gotten to truly test them out for lifting. At least not heavy. But what I’ve done in them has felt good. They have a decently wide toe box. A touch less wide than some of my other shoes that claim a wide toe box. But definitely not uncomfortable! Im also used to a little less of a drop. So these feel cushioned to me.